Scenic turns STOPS into VIAS if I change the routing and hit save
Quote from Hen_Dre91 on 14.04.2023, 08:38Hello,
I use Scenic with the swiss "game" Passknacker and therefore many STOPS on my routes are very important for my usage.
Unfortunately it happens very often (not sure when and how or if always) that Scenic turns my STOPS into VIAS if I change an already saved route.
F.E. a saved route has 11 STOPS, I realize I have not enough time and change the routing to "Include Highways" everything appears as normal. Then i hit save and all of a sudden my route has only like 3 STOPS and the other 8 STOPS turned into VIAS, which I don't always realize, while driving.
Is that a bug or a feature and what can I do to avoid it?
Hello,
I use Scenic with the swiss "game" Passknacker and therefore many STOPS on my routes are very important for my usage.
Unfortunately it happens very often (not sure when and how or if always) that Scenic turns my STOPS into VIAS if I change an already saved route.
F.E. a saved route has 11 STOPS, I realize I have not enough time and change the routing to "Include Highways" everything appears as normal. Then i hit save and all of a sudden my route has only like 3 STOPS and the other 8 STOPS turned into VIAS, which I don't always realize, while driving.
Is that a bug or a feature and what can I do to avoid it?
Quote from Guido on 14.04.2023, 09:01Hmmm... That's very strange indeed. Never heard this one before. Definitely a bug.
If I understand correct, this happens when you edit the route during navigation. In other words, when you double tap the map while navigating and then change the routing mode. Correct?I'm working on a big update at the moment and will look into this as a part of this update.
Hmmm... That's very strange indeed. Never heard this one before. Definitely a bug.
If I understand correct, this happens when you edit the route during navigation. In other words, when you double tap the map while navigating and then change the routing mode. Correct?
I'm working on a big update at the moment and will look into this as a part of this update.
Quote from Hen_Dre91 on 14.04.2023, 09:06Nope its all in planning mode. I am indeed sitting in front of my computer right now, planning my upcoming trip and it happened 2/2 times. 🙂
First time i added my homeadress as start point and second time i simply switched from "Vermeide Autobahn" to "Autobahn".
Not sure what you can see on the database but it happened to my saved route about 1 hour ago i guess, i already turned every VIA into a STOP manually already tho, renaming it to know which Passknacker I'm at, to take the evidence picture.
Not 2 big of a deal now that I'm home with my computer next to me, a bigger issue if I'm in the tent and setting my starting point for the upcoming ride 😉
MAYBE it has something to do with the "delete all VIA" function, when replanning a route, if VIAS are imported from f.e. Kurviger.de; It shouldn't delete STOPS then tho and also only does, when I hit the save button.
Nope its all in planning mode. I am indeed sitting in front of my computer right now, planning my upcoming trip and it happened 2/2 times. 🙂
First time i added my homeadress as start point and second time i simply switched from "Vermeide Autobahn" to "Autobahn".
Not sure what you can see on the database but it happened to my saved route about 1 hour ago i guess, i already turned every VIA into a STOP manually already tho, renaming it to know which Passknacker I'm at, to take the evidence picture.
Not 2 big of a deal now that I'm home with my computer next to me, a bigger issue if I'm in the tent and setting my starting point for the upcoming ride 😉
MAYBE it has something to do with the "delete all VIA" function, when replanning a route, if VIAS are imported from f.e. Kurviger.de; It shouldn't delete STOPS then tho and also only does, when I hit the save button.
Quote from Guido on 14.04.2023, 09:11Could you perhaps make a screen recording of this, so that I know exactly what you are doing and when it's happening? Then I can try and reproduce here.
Could you perhaps make a screen recording of this, so that I know exactly what you are doing and when it's happening? Then I can try and reproduce here.
Quote from Hen_Dre91 on 14.04.2023, 09:14I will try.
Okay I was able to recreate the situation. It dftly has something to do with the "Delete all VIAs" function to recalculate the route.
What you see is as follows:
- Import a random Route via Kurviger.de
- It has VIAS and 18 STOPS
- I saved the Route and went to my routes to change the route. Still VIAS and 18 STOPS.
- I change the navigation setting, Scenic wants to delete all VIAS to create a new route. Still 18 Stops.
- I hit the save button, Route now has 7 STOPS and 11 VIAS.
:/
Video comes in a minute.
edit: Video is now attached.
I will try.
Okay I was able to recreate the situation. It dftly has something to do with the "Delete all VIAs" function to recalculate the route.
What you see is as follows:
- Import a random Route via Kurviger.de
- It has VIAS and 18 STOPS
- I saved the Route and went to my routes to change the route. Still VIAS and 18 STOPS.
- I change the navigation setting, Scenic wants to delete all VIAS to create a new route. Still 18 Stops.
- I hit the save button, Route now has 7 STOPS and 11 VIAS.
:/
Video comes in a minute.
edit: Video is now attached.
Quote from Guido on 17.04.2023, 15:22Ok. Thanks for the video. Helps a lot. I watched it and see the bug. I’ll probably can fix this as part of the big update I’m working on.
Probably can have a beta with fix in it by Friday. If you’d like to beta test please could you send me an email through the email button at the bottom of the help page? Can always use a few more eyes in the beta test anyway.
Thanks again! Very helpful!
Ok. Thanks for the video. Helps a lot. I watched it and see the bug. I’ll probably can fix this as part of the big update I’m working on.
Probably can have a beta with fix in it by Friday. If you’d like to beta test please could you send me an email through the email button at the bottom of the help page? Can always use a few more eyes in the beta test anyway.
Thanks again! Very helpful!
Quote from Guido on 17.04.2023, 17:43Could you perhaps send me the GPX file you are importing? Want to make sure I'm testing with exact same circumstances. You can use the email button at the bottom of the help page.
Could you perhaps send me the GPX file you are importing? Want to make sure I'm testing with exact same circumstances. You can use the email button at the bottom of the help page.
Quote from Guido on 18.04.2023, 09:46I just tested this and I can confirm this bug will be fixed in the big update I'm working on.
P.S. This is currently only an issue if you use the 'send to scenic' button on the Kurviger website. With GPX import (even though it's a GPX from Kurviger), the import is a bit different as the GPX does not contains some routing information that is sent when using the 'Send to Scenic' button.
I just tested this and I can confirm this bug will be fixed in the big update I'm working on.
P.S. This is currently only an issue if you use the 'send to scenic' button on the Kurviger website. With GPX import (even though it's a GPX from Kurviger), the import is a bit different as the GPX does not contains some routing information that is sent when using the 'Send to Scenic' button.
