Difference between planned route and navigation
Quote from Tombal on 02.04.2024, 15:22Hi, I have been using Scenic for quite a long time and am very happy with the app.
Now, a route imported from myroute app is displayed to me in Scenic as planned. On the trip, during navigation, however, Scenic repeatedly wants to take me off the highway and then straight back on again, this on a 50km stretch of highway. Although it is easy to ignore this, it is still a bit unpleasant. Why is there a difference between the planned route and the navigation?This is the route: https://scenicapp.space/route/clJKzcPH
The problem occurred between the Via 3 and 8.
Hi, I have been using Scenic for quite a long time and am very happy with the app.
Now, a route imported from myroute app is displayed to me in Scenic as planned. On the trip, during navigation, however, Scenic repeatedly wants to take me off the highway and then straight back on again, this on a 50km stretch of highway. Although it is easy to ignore this, it is still a bit unpleasant. Why is there a difference between the planned route and the navigation?
This is the route: https://scenicapp.space/route/clJKzcPH
The problem occurred between the Via 3 and 8.
Quote from Guido on 04.04.2024, 07:48When was this route imported / planned? Was this perhaps with the old version of Scenic (pre 3.5?). If so, this could be the reason. Scenic 3.5 uses the new HERE maps, and new HERE routing algorytm.
When was this route imported / planned? Was this perhaps with the old version of Scenic (pre 3.5?). If so, this could be the reason. Scenic 3.5 uses the new HERE maps, and new HERE routing algorytm.
Quote from Tombal on 05.04.2024, 03:29Thanks für the reply. I updated to 3.5 before the Easter trip on which it happened, but only did the recent update afterwards.
Thanks für the reply. I updated to 3.5 before the Easter trip on which it happened, but only did the recent update afterwards.
Quote from Guido on 05.04.2024, 07:49Just to double check... did you also PLAN (save) the routes after you updated to 3.5?
Just to double check... did you also PLAN (save) the routes after you updated to 3.5?
Quote from Tombal on 05.04.2024, 08:13Yes, I have done that. But since it was the first and only time Scenic has done this so far, we can leave it at that. I would come back to the subject next time. Are there any important details that I need to consider next time in order to provide you with accurate information?
Yes, I have done that. But since it was the first and only time Scenic has done this so far, we can leave it at that. I would come back to the subject next time. Are there any important details that I need to consider next time in order to provide you with accurate information?
Quote from Guido on 05.04.2024, 08:19Thank you.
The most complete what you could provide me next time is: 1)... the share link to the route, 2) the share link to the ride and and 3) an indication where the routing was different during navigation then it was during planning.
Thank you.
The most complete what you could provide me next time is: 1)... the share link to the route, 2) the share link to the ride and and 3) an indication where the routing was different during navigation then it was during planning.
Quote from Knuspermuesli on 08.04.2024, 05:55Had exactly the same problem with a planned route from kurviger.de
Nearly every point I should leave my track, drive 100 m on another street, u-turn and back to the original track.
Wow that was annoying.Later it missed my points and brought me back to a route back home.
I stopped the route and did a new one directly in the app.Also "extra curvy" isn't usable.
I tried that. During the route scenic wanted that I am driving on a Autobahn and do a sharp turn left to leave the autobahn again.
I think I must not say that this is highly illegal to do so.
Had exactly the same problem with a planned route from kurviger.de
Nearly every point I should leave my track, drive 100 m on another street, u-turn and back to the original track.
Wow that was annoying.
Later it missed my points and brought me back to a route back home.
I stopped the route and did a new one directly in the app.
Also "extra curvy" isn't usable.
I tried that. During the route scenic wanted that I am driving on a Autobahn and do a sharp turn left to leave the autobahn again.
I think I must not say that this is highly illegal to do so.
Quote from Guido on 08.04.2024, 08:32I will see if I can improve the placement of the via points for curvy route generation. I general, I always recommend to check your imports and curvy generated routes for these "strange loops". Here is a help article on why these strange loops can occur. The article is about import, but the same is true for curvy generated routes.
I will see if I can improve the placement of the via points for curvy route generation. I general, I always recommend to check your imports and curvy generated routes for these "strange loops". Here is a help article on why these strange loops can occur. The article is about import, but the same is true for curvy generated routes.
